Are new sulphur products all they’re cracked up to be?

Written by Charmaine Mendez on Nov 19 2019

Category: Grow Grain

Breaking down the benefits and risks

Part of the market development agronomist job for Cargill is to sort through the information in the marketplace and to use our own experience to simplify your decisions on the farm. One of the most challenging spaces for competing information is the fertilizer market, and sulphur (S) products in particular.

Recently, a new slow-release sulphur product has hit the western Canadian market. It’s a compost product containing S particles and promising release of S over five years. Theoretically you apply it and you don’t need to add S for the next five years. However, there is not enough data to back up this theory.

With new products like this coming to market promising a variety of benefits, it’s time to break it down to four key considerations to separate the good from the questionable:

Plant availability.

Because elemental S is not available to plants and must be broken down to become available to the crop, many growers apply it as ammonium sulphate so it’s available in the current crop year. When applying elemental S, it must be done one to two years ahead of the crop it’s intended to feed. Some of the S in a slow-release product application will be available, but just how much is too difficult to predict.

Particle size matters.

The more finely ground the S particle, the more available it will be to the plant because each particle must be broken down by a microbial process involving water and oxygen. Products containing S particles of widely varying sizes will be less predictable in terms of when the crop will be able to use it. Products like MicroEssentials® S15™ and MicroEssentials SZ™ contain 15% and 10% S respectively, applied to fertilizer granules as a micronized coating. The S itself is a combination of elemental S and sulphate, meaning most of it breaks down in year one, leaving a small amount for the second year.

In the new slow release products, the S particles vary widely and as a result it’s difficult to predict just how long it will take them to break down into the plant-available form. Think inches versus micrograms. It’s an important consideration, because you need S for your canola crop when you need it, not at some point over a five-year span.

Soil pH affects performance.

Over time, elemental S increases acidity in the soil, and nutrient availability changes with acidity (pH of 6-8 range is good). Lower pH is when you see levels close to 6 (breaching to 5.7). If your soil pH is high (7.5-8) you could look at using a high organic matter, slow release product to bring it down. Ask yourself how many pounds you would need to apply to make this happen. 1,000 lb/ac? 10,000 lb/ac? What other issues might you cause because of these high rates?

Beware of other risks.

Always look critically at products that don’t have performance data to back them. Some products are made of composted material, but what’s in the load you receive? If you use it, you run the risk of also importing pests, pathogens or heavy metals. You need to ensure the compost is disease-free because you don’t want to introduce pathogens to your farm.

If you have questions about this or any other fertilizer product, or you’d like to look at your fertility plan with an expert, call your nearest Cargill location.

MicroEssentials is a registered trademark of The Mosaic Company. S15 and SZ are trademarks of The Mosaic Company.

Tags: Fertility, Soil, Nutrients, Sulphur, Canola, Compost


  • Cargill said Reply

    Hi Darcy,

    Glad to see you are considering critical nutrients for your fertilizer plan. Our recommendations change based on many cropping factors, so a Cargill representative would be happy to sit down and make a fertility plan customized to your farm and crop rotation.

    Sulphur can be a benefit early on and can be applied at seeding. Like all nutrients seed safety must be considered and the amount applied with the seed depends on seed bed utilization (SBU) and depends on the crop, soil type, moisture, row spacing and spread width of the opener. There are tables to calculate this available from Provincial Ag websites.

    This product in question is a blend of elemental sulphur and sulphate so the sulphate would be available right away for the crop at seeding with the elemental portion slowly released as it is broken down by the soil microbes to become plant available throughout the rest of the season and some may carry over until the following year.

    Thanks for your question

    Simon North
    Agronomy Technical Lead

  • Henry said Reply

    We have used Super S now for two years And it seems the elemental sulphur is breaking down very fast, last year it outyielded our AMS. Do you sell this product?

  • Ashley S said Reply

    Hi Henry,

    We are glad to hear you are having success by applying this Sulphur product. Unfortunately we do not sell this product but a good alternative would be S15 from MicroEssentials which is discussed in this article. S15 is 50% elemental and 50% sulphate so we believe you will get an even better yield response especially in the year of application than applying in a pure elemental form. It also has all the other benefits of having superior seed safety and has an homogeneous product for even distribution of the nutrients. This product is also supported by many years of independent trial data so we suggested you give it a try.

Add a Comment